I have an MK6 GTI and without a doubt it's one of the best cars. But the debate about the R being just slightly better than the GTI is not relevant anymore I think. I had an MK5 R32 and it is still my favorite all around within the cars I've had including R56 JCW and '08 M Coupe. Yes, the GTI can be tuned and brought to the performance close to the R, but will never provide the dinamics of the AWD. The MK7 R doesn't have the VR6 and the sexy sound of the R32, but it's the best R ever by finally bringing that desirable gap between the GTI. I'm anxiously waiting for the day when I can place an order for the car, but my MK6 is still going to stay in the stable as my daughter's daly driver. If the price difference is not an issue, go for it, you will never regret.