The 10 and 14 seem high.
What wheel did you buy?
What tires?
You could ask them to dismount the tire and see if moving could result in a better spot.
But they should have tried this.
my thoughts. i got enkei kojins 18x8 w 235/40/18 conti dws 06. they were scuffed up as well which makes me seriously question the technician's abilities
When tire place scuffs a new wheel, I make them replace it.
Did you buy wheel/tire package from tire rack or did local shop mount?
If Tire rack mounted I can share a suggestion.