[Old User]
Go Kart Champion
- Location
- steel city
I was originally talking about the older E46's, they are slow as fuck and stand no chance. there are very few E90's/ E92's around here where I live...
I still think it would be closer then you think but you're definitely right about the stage 1 GTI having nothing top end - the power comes in a huge lump around 4k and dies instantaneously at 5k. stage 2 could be a different story, but again, the IHI has nothing up top. better but still not fast.
On a different note I raced a C300 in my stock GTI and we were neck in neck till 90 then he pulled, N/A has the better top end like in the 328. now with the tune I don't see how I wouldn't destroy him.
I'm not saying the GTI is some fast race car by any means (GTI's are slow no matter what) but I do think stage 1 vs. an E90x 328i auto would be a decent race. stage 2 could probably take it. that 8 speed might be able to stay in powerband longer but the drivetrain loss thru the torque converter is pretty significant.
from a stop (irrelevant but interesting):
the lack of top end evidently doesn't make much difference at these speeds..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmVv2wQSvjs
I still think it would be closer then you think but you're definitely right about the stage 1 GTI having nothing top end - the power comes in a huge lump around 4k and dies instantaneously at 5k. stage 2 could be a different story, but again, the IHI has nothing up top. better but still not fast.
On a different note I raced a C300 in my stock GTI and we were neck in neck till 90 then he pulled, N/A has the better top end like in the 328. now with the tune I don't see how I wouldn't destroy him.
I'm not saying the GTI is some fast race car by any means (GTI's are slow no matter what) but I do think stage 1 vs. an E90x 328i auto would be a decent race. stage 2 could probably take it. that 8 speed might be able to stay in powerband longer but the drivetrain loss thru the torque converter is pretty significant.
from a stop (irrelevant but interesting):
the lack of top end evidently doesn't make much difference at these speeds..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmVv2wQSvjs