I have a Golf TDI and I'm running 17z calipers, kit from rotor labs. Golf TDI has the steel knuckles. Kit bolted on, but had to use carbide bit to shave down brake pad guide pins. I would also note that my driver side caliper is not perfectly centered over the rotor. Shop took a couple mil off of the pad to get it to fit. That was preferable to taking material off of the caliper mounting ears or knuckle itself. I need to take measurements of both sides with the calipers removed to figure out where the difference is because the passenger side is perfectly centered over the rotor. The rotor lab 18z kit will also bolt onto the steel knuckles and one other Golf TDI driver has that kit had no issues centering the calipers over his rotors.
Just depends on if you want to be able to run 17" wheels or not. The 17z has slightly more piston area than the 18z. The Golf has a smaller master cylinder and different brake booster than the GTI/R. I have no issue with brake pedal feel. I thought the stock brakes on the Golf were somewhat grabby and feel like I have better moderation now. Along with face in the windshield stopping power. For either you can use MK4 R32 front brake lines. Caliper end is correct and uses stock clip locations on the strut.
I'm using rotors from the rotorlab kit. I don't track my car and have a short (non TDI friendly) commute so I'm not going through pads or rotors with any pace. I don't know the offsets of the rotors so I'm not sure if other rotors will work with the rotorlab kit. IF you are considering his kit and choice of rotor is a concern definitely shoot them an email with the question. I honestly don't know if I'm stuck buying rotors from them forever.
The thing we really care about here, pictures... I'm on neuspeed rse05 with 10mm spacers for clearance...
Sent from my ONEPLUS A6013 using Tapatalk