Just wanted to give anybody looking at this thread a quick review of Supreme Power!
They really did give the best deal on Neuspeed wheels, they beat all the online prices I looked at, did an excellent job mounting the tires without nicking the rims. They also do powder coating since the wheels I wanted weren't offered in the color I wanted.
Their shop is extremely clean and well set-up. It was absolutely worth the 1.5 hour, each way, commute to have the wheels mounted and alignment done. Speaking of the alignment, they got it perfect all the way around, which isn't always easy on the Mk7.
First email to wheels/tires installed was 11 days.