The WeatherTech mats are certainly more protective than the Monster mats.
I had WeatherTech mats in my Mazda and they did the job. But I find that the hard plastic material is kind of slippery and gets really gritty under your feet, even with the slightest amount of dirt. I prefer the Monster mats as they're more soft rubber vs hard plastic.
Another knock on them was that the WeatherTech logo peeled off within the first year that I had them. The glue deteriorated for some reason.
Finally, they are way too expensive for what they are. Made in America, I believe. Not that that's a bad thing...
If someone else posted a good comparison video between the two on here let e me know and I'll take the post down.
This man people are rages.
Solid video and I love my weathertechs.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk
Compare what they both look like after 10 years use.