Cuzoe
Autocross Champion
- Location
- Los Angeles
There's a non-zero chance I'll be going back to my manual HVAC until such time as I do full climatronic retrofit. I've got the touch climatronic panel installed, although I don't know if that is making a diffeernce.Following up on my earlier post. I thought I'd figured out how to get the recirc flap to function correctly with a coding change, but the result was the recirc mode being reversed from what's indicated on the Climatronic panel! My windows were fogging up in cold weather even with the A/C on (mostly when the whole family was in the car), so I finally looked up into the cabin filter slot to confirm. I switched the coding back to original even though that means it's not 100% fresh when in that setting.
I think we (meaning budget retrofit Climatronic folks) will have to accept some recirc flap wonkiness, because the servo and wiring is different on factory Climatronic cars. (Why did VW do this for recirc and defrost servos?! I'd think those things would function the same for both HVAC types.)
This is the wiring diagram for the Climatronic recirc servo, which has 4 wires and is identified as V425 (with G44 position sensor):
...
Meanwhile, manual HVAC cars have 2 wires to a servo named V113:
...
What I don't get is that I can read the recirc door position in VCDS even with the 2-wire servo. But it appears that a different servo and additional wiring are needed for full compatibility. Anyone found something different?
The HVAC is all over the place with directing air. When I leave it in Auto it seems to be hunting flap positions. I'll get air blowing on my face, then feet, then upper (defrost) vents, then back, all pretty random. Until last week I had not needed to defrost but when I select Max Defrost it's giving me what I think is a mix of air on my face and from the upper (defrost vents). The front window did de-fog so air is going up there but it certainly isn't right. I haven't even logged the position of the recirc flap but I have to assume it has the same issue everyone (who is looking) is seeing.
The temperature regulation is quite good (have both vent, the foot and sun sensor installed). I also have the air quality sensor installed and it did switch to recirc mode one day as I got back into the valley where the air quality generally sucks (it's bad enough that we get the alerts on our phones).
If everything (besides dual zone, obviously) worked I could live with the various faults. But since it doesn't my inclination is go back to manual. HVAC is the only module in my scan with faults... or at least with faults I didn't induce and therefore cannot resolve.