Ok folks, the hard-hitting info you have been craving! Or not....
Pertinent background info:
Car. 2018 Golf Sportwagen w/4Motion. IS38. Unitronic ECU/TCU tunes. United Haldex tune. B8s/H&R springs/H&R front/rear sway bars/Eurosport mounts/Superpro LCAs. APR 350mm BBK. ESC OFF typically (or Sport). XDS weak. Straight ahead brake stabilization and Hydraulic brake assistant deactivated. My wagon weighs ~3,500 pounds with me in it.
Driver. I have 17 days on track at this point since starting this 3 years ago. I’m a solid upper intermediate driver at this point in the groups I have been running with. HPDE only. I drive to live/drive my car home from the track. At this point I can consistently turn 2:18-2:20 laps at VIR.
Brakes. I’m coming off APR’s “Advanced Track Day” pads which worked great but are very expensive (~$600). I run EBC Bluestuff NDX in the rear with the small-ish 272x10mm solid rotors (same as came on the non-PP GTI) which have limited pad choices w/r to track-focused compounds. The NDX version are a higher-torque compound than the regular Bluestuff at 0.52Mu with a MOT of 1000 deg F. I run Motul RBF600 fluid with a fresh bleed before each event. I purchased both sets of pads from buybrakes.com and you can find discount codes frequently. EBC has some good info on these two pad models here (I’d say based on my experience this info is spot-on):
Should I choose RP-1™ or RP-X™ Pads? - EBC Brakes
EBC RP-1 front brake pads
I had 3 days on the RP-1s, one at Summit Point Shenandoah and two at VIR. ~3K street miles. Pads started at 9.5mm of friction material and were worn quite unevenly with taper back to front and more wear to almost the backing plate on the inners. Not sure there, haven’t had abnormal uneven wear before now.
The brake feel is very different than the APR track pads I had previously that I’m sure have a much higher torque value (not listed). The RP-1s have a lot more pedal feel/modulation due to their lower Mu at 0.45. They made it v. easy to trail brake as I could really push the pedal during braking allowing me more travel to come off of to trail brake/modulate vs. before where the brake seemed to be at full-steam after a lighter touch of the pedal making the easing off more challenging. The RP-1s are rated at ~1,400 deg F MOT so similar to many other track compounds out there. They were fine for daily use over the last few mos. with good (but mellow) cold bite (was below freezing here recently and no issues) and the dust isn’t as bad as the APR pads that seemed to form hardened piles that were a bitch to remove…the RP-1 dust cleans up easily with a bit of wheel cleaner/soap/brush and a hose but are still v. dusty as they are a track compound. I had no noise at all on the street. I actually quite like these for street pads.
At VIR I struggled with more rear end squirm than I had previously and I’m attributing that to the rear Mu being higher/mismatched than the front while slowing from 130+ at the higher speed straights at VIR. It was clear however that the rears were having to put in more work…I used almost all of my brand new rear pads in 2 days! Starting friction material thickness was 10.5mm and now 2-4mm with tapered wear on the front vs. back. The RP-1s were dead solid both days and even over the last longer 40 min session, no issues with fade or pedal feel changes on track….just felt like I had to push them harder is really all which I wasn’t used to, and they didn’t inspire confidence in the higher-speed braking zones like the higher Mu pads I had previously did.
EBC RP-X front brake pads
I had ~2 days on the RP-Xs at VIR. Less than 1K street miles.
The RP-X have a bit higher MOT than the RP-1s at ~1500 and a higher friction coefficient at 0.55 Mu. After install/prior to bedding these had a shocking initial bite on the street and provide VERY strong braking. After swapping to new rotors, mating them up and getting them bed in, they didn’t seem as graby as they were on the old rotors. At VIR this past weekend, they were great and I was able to brake much later/achieve my highest top speed on the back and front straights (141, 136, respectively) b/c I was confident with the braking. The weird squirm with the RP-1s/Bluestuff NDX due to the mis-matched Mu was completely gone. Smooth straight braking with the RP-X and Bluestuff NDX. After a day and change of track use they were sitting at 6-6.5mm of friction material down from 9.5mm to start so about 35% used. Wear was about as even as expected with some minor taper/variation but nothing like the RP-1s. Rears looked good with only min. wear indicating they were not working as hard as they had with the RP-1s. These should last 2-3 weekends at most is my takeaway so not a long-lasting pad on my heavier car but commensurate with the lower $200s price tag (buybrakes.com coupons/discounts are easy to find). Note that the $600 APR pads lasted 10.5 hours ($57/hour track time) and the RP-X is projected to last about half of that so call it 6 hours ($37/hour track time) so overall a lower cost but changing the pads more often. To be fair, I wasn't driving as hard on the APR pads as I progressed so they may not last as long now but I have to believe they will still outlast the EBCs.
Now that I’ve had both types of pads, I prefer a higher torque pad with higher initial bite (how do you know unless you try?). EBC notes that the RP-1 is for lighter cars and I’d say that is accurate…my wagon is just too heavy for them as evidenced by going through them and the rears so quickly. I’d buy the RP-X again but I'd try other popular track pads by Ferodo (1.11 or 3.13), Carbotec (10 or 12), G-Loc (10 or 12), and PFC (08 I believe is the compound that folks often use).
Some videos of using the RP-X at VIR last weekend with TSCC: