hey, thanks for the feedback! I'm sure that modded '11 STI was a blast to drive, but I have to agree with you on the car's rattles. I was just complaining about that to my girlfriend the other day.
I've only tracked my sti a few times (2-3 maybe) in the almost-5-years of ownership so I doubt I would be tracking the Golf-R much, if at all. I have a 2014 ZX6R and I MUCH prefer doing motorcycle track days...much more fun and more skill involved!!!
As for the Focus RS, that one was eliminated from the list for a few reasons. First off it's way too pricey (here a new one sells for $49,500 lowest which is about $6,000 more than the Golf DSG), I despise the interior, and most reviews stated it really was not as much of a daily as the Golf R is (loud, less comfortable, suspension too stiff etc). Also I don't believe the resale will be very good. Must admit it is quite the vehicle though!
Gotcha, you can find new RS's down here cheap, the hype train has left, guess its with Honda now lol
Ya, if you're basically talking street car, dsg golf R with a stage 1 tune is a pretty sweet little setup. I've got a 16 setup that way and a more modded 17, both are really nice dd. I continue to be impressed, damn decent in snow also with snow wheels/tires. I was one of those guys that swore I'd never spend that kinda $$$ on a hot hatch lol. Now I don't know why you'd spend 40gs any other way on a dd.
They really are a cut above, sti's, evo's, focus rs's for every day livability. A stock dsg R wins the drag race against any of those stock for stock, launch control is a beautiful thing. And a tuned dsg R will hand every one of those versions tuned its ass at a stoplight, even if they have heavy bolt ons, in most cases. Vw has a pretty nice hot hatch as a daily driver and the cars really come alive compared to their competitors with the aftermarket.
Good luck, only a few more months of rattles