I live in south eastern PA as well (Lehigh Valley) and recently bought the R. Came from a WRX so I valued the AWD - never really considered the GTI although I agree there seems to be much better deals on them. Tough to say if the R is worth the price difference since the interior of the higher end GTI's are pretty much identical but, to me, the comfort of having the AWD was it. Also, am liking the DCC so far. Was looking for a ride that was less stiff than the WRX and so far the R fits the bill - particularly if i put it in comfort mode.